blank    blank
banner

Ethical Dilemma Case Study: Integrity & Ethics



  Sep 07, 2023

Ethics and Integrity:Ethical Dilemma Case Study


College Student's Draw to Civil Services for Power & Privileges

A college student aiming to become a civil servant in India shares with a senior officer that they are drawn to the position by a desire for power and privileges. How can the senior officer guide the student in this situation? Provide a range of advice options and recommend the best course of action along with the reasons.
 

Analysis:

Civil services are built on the foundation of public welfare and ethical behavior. While power and privileges might come as a part of the job, they are not the core essence of civil services. Hence, it's essential to ensure that aspirants have the right motivations.
 

Potential Solutions & Recommendations:

 
Guided Self-Reflection:
 
Action: Engage the student in a conversation to introspect on their motivations.
 
Outcome: The student might discover deeper or additional motivations, or recognize the mismatch between their aspirations and the core values of civil services.
 

Emphasize Service Over Power:

Action: Highlight real-life examples of civil servants making a difference. Share stories of personal satisfaction derived from serving society.
 
Outcome: It might shift the student's focus from power to service.
 

Introduction to Core Values:

Action: Discuss the importance of ethical behavior, integrity, and honesty in civil services.
 
Outcome: The student understands the non-negotiable foundational values of the profession.
 

Projection of Long-Term Career:

Action: Discuss the long-term implications of joining with the wrong motivations and the potential dissatisfaction it can lead to.
 
Outcome: The student might reassess their decision considering the long-term journey.
 

Suggesting Alternative Paths:

Action: Discuss other professions or roles where their motivation for power and control might be more aligned, like entrepreneurship or corporate leadership.
 
Outcome: The student might find a more suitable and satisfying career path.
 

Recommended Course of Action:

Given the student's current mindset, it's vital first to engage in Guided Self-Reflection. This will help them understand their motivations better. Following this, emphasizing the Service Over Power and introducing them to the Core Values of civil services can provide a clearer picture of what the profession truly entails. If their motivations remain unchanged, suggesting Alternative Paths is a proactive approach to ensure their long-term satisfaction and success.
 
By guiding the student through these steps, the senior officer ensures that the student makes an informed and thoughtful decision about their career path.


Share:
 

Get a call back

Fill the below form to get free counselling for UPSC Civil Services exam preparation

 
UPSC DAILY CURRENT AFFAIRS

 
​BUSAN & PLASTIC POLLUTION CRISIS: FACTS, CHALLENGES, AND GLOBAL RESPONSE
 
UNESCO’s International Decade of Science for Sustainable Development (2024-2033)- Harnessing Science for a Sustainable Future:
 
​COP-29 OUTCOMES AND EXPECTATIONS FOR COP-30
 
CLIMATE CHANGE CASE IN INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE (ICJ)
 
The International North South Transport Corridor (INSTC) New Route: A Boost for Indo Russian Trade
 
​ecDNA: The Circular DNA Driving Cancer
 
Personality Rights: Protecting Identity and Image-The Case of Dr.Devi Shetty
 
PLACES OF WORSHIP (SPECIAL PROVISIONS) ACT, 1991: STOCKTAKE
 
​Daimabad: Deccan Chalcolithic Meets Harappans-FAQs
 
UNCCD COP16:16th Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification: Basics
 
The NCQG: A Critical Analysis of the New Collective Quantified Goal for Climate Finance
 
India's Critically Endangered Species: Explainer
 
The Tebhaga Movement: North Bengal's Fight for a Fairer Share
 
​HORNBILL FESTIVAL
 
Kattaikkūttu from Tamil Nadu